[Ascaloth/Akira] Nodame Cantabile ~Paris Chapter~, Episode 3

LagannGurren LagannDai GurrenArk Gurren LagannDaiginga Gurren Lagann! (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...
Popularity: 9% [?]

Episode 3 marks the return of everybody’s favourite perverted Maestro Franz von Stresemann to the fray, much to the delight of many who considered him the source of most of last season’s comedic moments. And with the Platini Conductor Competition over, things are just getting started in Paris, as Chiaki wastes no time - or rather, is not allowed to - while Nodame continues to play catch-up with her new stint as a Conservatoire student. Thankfully unlike the previous episode, the dice-and-chop of source material returns to an acceptable level in this episode, so I believe most of you would be glad to see me not dissing this episode nearly as hard as I did last week. So my offer; let bygones be bygones, as we go into the third episode of the Paris Chapter.

Nodame Cantabile ~Paris Chapter~, Episode 3.

Comment allez-vous!

Sometimes, there are just things that never change.

It’s kind of amusing how Stresemann uses the same method of checking for dust that military sergeants do for recruits. Or maybe Nodame’s piano is really just that unused, probably because she has been using Chiaki’s instead.

Quick question; since when and how did Chiaki get himself kidnapped by Elize and Oliver? Actually, I know the answer to those questions, but I’ll rather like to hear what the first-time viewers think of what seems at first glance to be a non sequitur scene.

Awww, they cut out Elize’s Zeus-Prometheus speech. Not that it meant much of anything, but it was somewhat amusing. Anyway, does this count as cruel and unusual punishment?

Frank wants some of that ‘D’ too.

Of the respected figures in our history, both past and present, one has to wonder just how many of them are, like Stresemann, not at all as dignified as their reputation makes them out to be. If only we could see the LULZ that ensues were we to know just how undignified some of them could be in real life….oh wait, we already did.

But as much of an erojiji as he might really be in real life, the man is still worthy of his reputation as Maestro, and ultimately despite his failing, even Chiaki who knows these failings well recognizes that in the end. Not that it means much of anything, but one line that I think J.C. Staff left out had Chiaki thinking to himself that "I can’t say I’m not happy" to be ‘forced’ to go on a concert tour with the Maestro. Stresemann still commands a great deal of respect solely from his skill with music alone.

Sometimes, it’s just the little things that really matter. Despite all the yellings and the violence, for Chiaki it’s the small gestures that really reveal how he really feels about Nodame.

Unfortunately, this episode shows us something that is unfortunately common in real life; that the ambitions of a person can sometimes keep that person away from his or her treasured ones for a period of time. Pretty sad, but then again, that’s life for you. It’s something some of us will have to face in a later part of our lives.

Introducing Li Yunlong, another one of the new friends Nodame makes in Paris. There was a scene in the manga missing from this episode implying that the presence of Yunlong influences the Chiaki-Nodame relationship a bit, but otherwise he’s fairly peripheral to the whole deal.

I am amused at how J.C. Staff decided to use actual Chinese characters as opposed to kanji, though. That was pretty funny, and quite apt considering Yunlong’s identity.

Unfortunately, I sometimes feel like Tanya has a point there. Especially in a university which grades on a bell curve, one really is not just studying on one’s own terms, but is in effect competing with people one meets on a daily basis and calls "friends". Competition has become

Featured Piece: Frédéric Chopin’s Nocturne Op. 27, No. 2 in D-flat Major

"Technically known as the Op. 27, No. 2. Named No. 8 because it’s Chopin’s eigth nocturne, surprise surprise.

While not as nearly as insane as any of Liszt’s compositions, this one still requires a fair amount of skill, but also a great deal of interpretive power. It’s simple, written in binary form (which means it only has two main themes), in D-flat major. There are sections which require lots of attention and detail, especially to tempo."  - Akira, The Nihon Review

"Chopin’s music frequently uses a musicial technique called "rubato" (robbed time), in which a preformer is allowed to speed up and slow down the tempo (but not unreasonably) to his liking in order to suit his interpretation of the piece. Depending on who you’re listening to, you might hear a lot or a little bit of rubato in this specific nocturne. There are places where it becomes very passionate, and other places where it becomes very quiet. Technically demanding, yes, but even more so emotionally. No, it really isn’t possible to play this piece of music just by looking at it." - Akira

Remember how Nodame said she was glad that Chiaki didn’t get a piano concerto for his final round, since she was going to be the first to play a piano concerto with him? Yep. Although Nodame acts depressed about seeing Chiaki with other women in the photos, one might realize that in the end she doesn’t take them all that seriously; she bounces right back from them, and doesn’t act all jealous like most women might. However, she views Son Rui getting the jump on her for Chiaki’s partner in the piano concerto as a serious betrayal by the latter of her instead. One might be puzzled by Nodame’s way of thinking, but then again, the minds of true artists thinks differently from the rest of us.

Although the appearance of Son Rui adds another dimension to the Chiaki-Nodame relationship, the fact that she’s not just a cameo character and in fact, will become a recurring character later on if this series gets that far, makes me worry that discussion about the Paris Chapter will fall victim to that which is scourge of all discussion on anime blogs and forums these days; the Shipping Wars Scourge. Seriously, I hope I don’t have to see any shipping in the future, particularly because Nodame Cantabile is nothing like that. XD

Nodame plays the same piece that Rui is playing here later on, so I’ll add Akira’s analysis on it then.

I wonder if RIUVA CEO TJ Han can attest that this is one of those things a guy has to expect when he spends his time with a girl?

I’ll be brutally honest here, this scene made me go LOLWUT. Chiaki’s the kind of guy who keeps his romantic displays to a minimum, with concessions made only to the small gestures and/or extraordinary circumstances. That’s the Chiaki we know from the manga, the live-action, and if I recall correctly, even back in the first season. He wasn’t supposed to be so blatantly…..moé. XD

I never cease to be amused at Chiaki comparing Nodame to a pet cat in his mind, not least because it’s probably an appropriate comparison.


"There are a lot of Chiaki-sempais here."

As far as I remember, that is an anime-original line, and actually quite funny in addition to being fairly creative. Certainly, it does portray quite accurately the difficulties that Nodame is facing in the Conservatoire, and pretty much makes up for what they cut out here.

Featured Piece: Franz Liszt’s Transcendental Etude no. 4 in D minor "Mazeppa"

"WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS SHIT?!" - Akira, when presented with the score for Mazeppa (No. 4, in D Minor)

"An "etude" is, literally, a "study." It’s supposed to hone your skill in one particular area of piano technique. But not this one. This etude tests your ability to FUCKING PLAY the piano!!!!

I can not stress how difficult this piece is. There’s a reason why these etudes are called the "Transcendental" etudes; they TRANSCEND EVERY HUMAN BEING’S PLAYING ABILITY. To play this is to literally become a piano god. I’m not even joking about this." - Akira

The Transcendental Etudes were only the third version of a series of 12 compositions that Liszt has ever written, and they are the most often recorded version of the three. It was first published as the Étude en douze exercices in 1826, when Liszt was only 15 years old. Later on in 1837, Liszt revised the series and published a second version the next year, titled Douze Grandes Etudes. This version is the one that I linked to Akira’s exclamation earlier, and it is considered the most technically challenging version of what is already considered amongst the most difficult piano pieces ever written.

"So yes, we could talk about the music. The fact that it’s crazy. There’s chromatic scales all over the damn place, the entire piece is played at (literally) breakneck speed. There are parts where it slows down, and musically, it does follow a main theme, but the breaks are few and extremely far between. Most of the piece is made up of fast-paced scales, leaping full-piano arpeggios and massive amounts of difficult rhythms. What’s even worse, Liszt specifically fingered the piece weirdly so anyone trying to play the piece (correctly) would have a hard time maneuvering his fingers in a correct manner. It’s all a giant test designed to see if you really know how to play the piano.

Leaping chords also make this a nightmare for anyone with small hands. The chords are literally HUGE. Not only are they huge, but they are also FAST. Everyone knows that chords played at an extremely fast tempo is one of THE most challenging things to do correctly in piano. Liszt spared no quarter when creating this piece. He really did want to make sure that anyone who played this was indeed a master at the piano." - Akira

 The level of virtuosity demanded by Douze Grandes Etudes was such that Robert Schumann declared that at the time, they were playable by "at the most, ten or twelve players in the world". Realizing that none can match his virtuosity, Liszt yet again revised and published the third version in 1852, creating a dumbed-down version eventually known today as the Études d’exécution transcendante, or the Transcendental Etudes.

"That being said, there is a huge difference being ABLE to play this and playing it WELL. In a piece like this (a symphonic poem), simply being able to hit the notes, while impressive, is NOT going to get you any accolades. You have to play it WELL. One needs to be able to actually let the audience HEAR the gallop of the horse, the pain of the man being dragged, and the man’s eventual triumph over the horse. Simply striking notes won’t achieve that… one must be KEENLY attuned to the fluxes in articulation, in dynamics, all of that. This is probably why Nodame fails at playing this piece; she simply shows off her technical skill instead of actually playing the piece with feeling and interpretation." - Akira

The 4th Transcendental Etude, "Mazeppa", is based on Victor Hugo’s poem of the same name, which in turn was inspired by Lord Byron’s dramatic poem of yet again the same name. It tells the tale of an Ukrainian youth who was strapped naked onto a wild horse which was then set loose, after his involvement in a scandal with the wife of a gentleman. The youth barely survives the ordeal, and later rises to become the hetman (leader) of the Cossacks of Ukraine. It was loosely based on the life of Ivan Mazepa, a real-life Cossack Hetman in 1687–1708.

Sometimes, in the course of our life pursuit, we lose track of what is truly important, and sometimes even why we embarked on the pursuit in the first place. Sometimes, we confuse what we really wish for in our hearts as our goal for embarking on a pursuit, not realizing that it doesn’t naturally happen that way. Sometimes, it’s a good idea to just pause at a particular moment in one’s life, and review what one is workings towards, and what for. And that is one of the main underlying themes of the Paris Chapter, as both Chiaki and Nodame take the time to think about the reasons for their own actions and choices they’ve made. Things have never been easy for them despite all the comedy and hijinks the both of them had gotten up to, but it’s just going to get harder from here.

Ascaloth, out.

Popularity: 9% [?]

Click now to visit J-List!

5 Responses to “[Ascaloth/Akira] Nodame Cantabile ~Paris Chapter~, Episode 3”  

  1. 1 Loba 86 comments

    Guessing Chiaki got drunk and walked into the same toilet at oliver who promptly alerted Eliza and initated Operation Desert?

  2. 2 Sorrow-kun 26 comments

    Another highly informative review from the two of you again. Good job. You guys are really putting effort into this.

    Largely agree with this review, even as someone who hasn’t read the source material. It was a good episode, but something’s still lacking compared to the first episode. It’s hard to put a finger on exactly what that “something” is, but it’s to do with the mood of the show. It’s just not quite as “fun” as the first season (even if it is still one of the better shows of the season).

  3. 3 tj_han 1440 comments

    Why would anyone not carry the bags? It makes sense because to us, the bags are as light as cotton candy but those useless girls have arms only strong enough to put on makeup!

  4. 4 The Sojourner 112 comments

    Nodame is more of a dog than a cat to me.

  5. 5 escaru 3 comments

    Yay Mazeppa! Having played the orchestral symphonic poem version of this piece, I can attest that it’s very difficult to play, at least for the violins. Still, it’s one of my favorite pieces of music to listen to.

Do not use any < and > for your own sake. It will end the comment there and then. Also, there is an automatic IQ filter which weeds out comments made by those who accidentally got transported from the stone age.

Leave a Reply



What would you like to see more of here?

View Results

Featured Feeds

Most Commented Posts

Counter

  • 17 currently online
  • 88 maximum concurrent
  • 4229336 total visitors
E2046 - The GK e-Shop